| Sarah Carvajal Dating Death | Colum Coleman The Legend of Barak Nor |
| Jenna Hren A Walk Amidst the Woods | Evan Howell Red Wings |
| Amanda Layne Jesse | Mike Neis Waking on the Shore |
| Corynne Nuckols Bobby’s Run | Sean Phelan The Artist |
| Emily Ruby Ruby | Yash Seyedbagheri Cat Eyes |
| Hannah Sloan A Mortal Story | Parker Stenseth Consuming Gethsemane |